Old Shadowfang Keep - Worth the Effort?

Located to the north of Pyrewood Village, Shadowfang Keep was once a bastion of Alliance power, but now it serves as the dark residence of Arugal, a mad former mage of the Kirin Tor. While some may see this location as an attractive option for acquiring rare items, I believe that Old Shadowfang Keep is slightly overrated compared to alternative options.

For rogues in particular, I think purchasing Old Shadowfang Keep would be a total waste. The drop rate on certain items is around 10%, which is much lower than the 0.01% chance of obtaining the same item through other means. Furthermore, the bonus provided by Old Shadowfang Keep (+4-8 Shadow damage) offers little to no benefit for rogues.

In contrast, Cruel Barb provides a more substantial increase in attack power, resulting in a higher DPS output. While the difference may seem significant at first glance, it's actually quite small, with Old Shadowfang Keep only providing an additional 0.1 seconds of speed and a damage range of (29-55). Meanwhile, Cruel Barb offers a wider damage range of (30-57), making it a more effective choice for rogues.

Another consideration is the fact that Old Shadowfang Keep can only be used as a main hand item, limiting its versatility. In contrast, Cruel Barb can be used in both main and off-hand positions, allowing for greater flexibility in combat.

In conclusion, while Old Shadowfang Keep may have some benefits, I believe it's overrated compared to alternative options like Cruel Barb. For rogues looking to optimize their DPS output, I would recommend exploring other options before investing in Old Shadowfang Keep.

Old shadowfang keep